Tomboy (album)

Following the success of his previous album Person Pitch (2007) and Animal Collective's Merriweather Post Pavilion (2009), Lennox was looking to move beyond the restrictions of composing with a sampler and record something "with a heavy focus on guitar and rhythm," influenced by bands like Nirvana and the White Stripes;^[7] he later qualified that these artists' influence should not be taken too literally, as "their sound is over-driven and buzzed out and that wasn’t something I was really into. But […] it was exciting to see that from a simple set up, these bands can crank out some really heavy jams. I think I just took inspiration from that kind of approach.”^[8] He also mentioned being inspired by the singing of "Frank Sinatra or crooner guys. It’s a really singular thing, but really powerful, too."^[9]

In contrast to Person Pitch, which was recorded in his well-lit apartment overlooking Lisbon, Tomboy was recorded in a basement studio where "there was no light, it was really dark and it was kind of lonely."^[8] During the sessions, Lennox ran his guitar through a Korg M3-M workstation module, which is commonly part of a synthesizer.^[10] He explained that he "had this idea of a triangle where the voice was at the top, some sort of guitar element on one side, and then some sort of really basic rhythm on the other side.^[10] The song "Benfica" is a reference to the Portuguese football club S.L. Benfica.^[11]

In an interview with NYCTaper in September 2010, Josh Dibb of Animal Collective revealed that he and bandmate Dave Portner had been requested to mix the album on its completion.^[12] However, due to the fact that both of them were busy at the time, it was later reported that the album was being mixed by Sonic Boom, former Spacemen 3 member and producer of MGMT's second album, Congratulations.^[13]

Lennox noted that his original mix of the album "sampled a lot of these little children’s movies that my daughter was watching at the time […] I just remember hearing this sonic clutter in the house all the time." He noted that Sonic Boom's mix made these less obvious but "I’m hoping that those sorts of things will make it feel a little more weird, like a broadcast coming from space."^[8]

Lennox had mentioned that Tomboy's release would be similar to that of Person Pitch in that several singles would be released on different labels prior to its release, "Doing the singles helps me focus on every song and also helps me move along in the process."^[7] The first single, "Tomboy" was released on Paw Tracks July 13, 2010, with a digital release following a week later. The first and only pressing sold out quickly. Another two singles, "You Can Count on Me" and "Last Night at the Jetty", were released later in the year on Domino and FatCat respectively. "Surfer's Hymn", the last of the four planned singles, was released by Kompakt on March 28 with a remix by London musician Actress.^[14] According to his website, Tomboy was slated for release "near the end of 2010".^[7]

On January 14, 2011, Lennox announced via Facebook that the album would be released on April 19 of that year,^[15] and it was later moved up a week to April 12 so it would be available on Record Store Day.^[16] Two listening parties for the album were held in New York City on February 16, and another two in Los Angeles on February 28.^{[citation needed]} The first 1000 pressings of the vinyl were printed on translucent wax, and initial copies of the album came with a download card redeemable for a free digital copy of Live at Governor's Island, a recording of a New York show by Panda Bear from September 11, 2010. A limited edition box set for the album was released on November 1, 2011 with all proceeds going to the American Cancer Society. It contains four LPs featuring: the Tomboy full length with slightly different mixing on two LPs, Noah's single mixes on one LP, and several Tomboy unreleased instrumentals and a cappellas, plus "The Preakness" and a 16-page art booklet. ^{[citation needed]}

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.5/10[17]
Metacritic	77/100[18]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[19]
The A.V. Club	A−[4]
Entertainment Weekly	B+[20]
The Guardian	[21]
Los Angeles Times	[22]
Mojo	6/10[23]
Paste	7.1/10[3]
Pitchfork	8.5/10[24]
Q	[25]
Rolling Stone	[26]
Slant Magazine	6/10[27]

Rolling Stone stated that "the rapturous beauty on the Animal Collective singer's fourth solo disc is built on basic stuff: Lennox's choirboy tenor – multiplied into billowing harmonies – and sweet melodies," but called it "a bit less stunning" than Person Pitch.^[26] The Guardian called the album "dense, oppressive and utterly hypnotic," and praised Lennox's "honeyed, glowing vocal harmonies, repeated and repeated until they induce not a headache, but a calming trance."^[21] Entertainment Weekly stated that the album "stretches out Beach Boys-style pop into a kind of slo-mo sound installation. The woozy, reverb-rich result makes for great headphone swimming."^[20] According to The Quietus, the album reflected "a more streamlined assimilation of all the classic Panda Bear touchstones: 60s psych-pop, drone, techno and folk," stating that 'by shedding many of his more irksome tropes, he lets his true craftsmanship shine through."^[28]

Paste noted that the album "scales back on many of the infectious samples that made his third LP such an appealing record, instead inviting us into his own lush ambient-pop landscapes," but cautioned that Lennox occasionally "succumbs to the weight of his somewhat ambivalent, drudging experiments."^[3] Slant Magazine claimed that "it’s difficult not to be slightly disappointed by the despondent nature of Lennox’s fourth solo album," adding that "though rich and dreamlike, Panda Bear’s latest is too tedious, too bloated, and far too serious to be anything more than an above-average record."^[27]

Pitchfork placed the album at number 32 on its list of the "Top 50 albums of 2011".^[29]

Rolling Stone placed the album at number 37 on its list of the "Top 50 albums of 2011".^[30]