Odd Fellows

Several theories aim to explain the etymological background of the name "Odd Fellows," often spelled "Oddfellows" in British English. In the 18th century United Kingdom, major trades were organised in guilds or other forms of syndicates, but smaller trades did not have equivalent social or financial security. One theory has it that "odd fellows", people who exercised unusual, miscellaneous "odd trades", eventually joined together to form a larger group of "odd fellows."^[11]

Another theory suggests that in the beginning of odd fellowship in the 18th century, at the time of the early era of industrialisation, it was rather odd to find people who followed noble values such as fraternalism, benevolence and charity.^{[11][need quotation to verify]} The name was supposedly adopted at a time when the severance into sects and classes was so wide that persons aiming at social union and mutual help were a marked exception to the general rule.^[12] Possibly, it met a mixed reaction from the upper classes, who may have seen them as a source of revenue by taxes, but also as a threat to their authority.^[13]

Any suggestion of history before the 18th century is considered mere speculation.^[14]

The Odd Fellows are one of the earliest and oldest fraternal societies, but their early history is obscure and largely undocumented.

Traditions tracing the fraternity's origins back to Roman emperors Nero and Titus are considered dubious.^[15] The evolution of the society from medieval guilds, however, is more reliably documented.^[a]

By the 13th century, tradesmen's guilds had become established and prosperous. During the 14th century, guild masters moved to protect their power and wealth by restricting access to the guilds. In response, the less experienced and less wealthy fellows established their own rival guilds.^{[b][2][16][4][17][need quotation to verify], [18][need quotation to verify], [2][need quotation to verify]}

When Henry VIII broke with the Roman Catholic Church, he viewed the guilds as supporting the pope, and in 1545 he confiscated all material property of the guilds. Elizabeth I stripped the guilds of the responsibility for training apprentices, and by the end of her reign, most guilds had been suppressed.^{[13][2][16][4]}

The exact origin of Oddfellowship is involved in obscurity. It must have had a beginning, but just when and where, no historian has ever been able to ascertain. All of its history prior to the introduction of the Order into England is merely conjecture founded upon proofless, and, in most cases, absurd traditions.

— "History" page of the Grand United Order of Odd Fellows in America^[19]

Great antiquity has been claimed for the order ... Oddfellows themselves, however, now generally admit that the institution cannot be traced back beyond the first half of the 18th century.

— Encyclopædia Britannica (1911)^[12]

There were numerous Oddfellow organizations in England in the 1700s.^[20] One Edwardian Oddfellow history argued that in 1710 there was a 'Loyal Lintot of Oddfellows' in London.^[21] The first Oddfellows group in South Yorkshire, England, dates from 1730.^[22] The earliest surviving documented evidence of an “Oddfellows” lodge is the minutes of Loyal Aristarchus Oddfellow Lodge no. 9 in England, dated 12 March 1748. By it being lodge number 9, this connotes that there were older Oddfellows lodges that existed before this date.^[23]

Subsequent to the failure of Bonnie Prince Charlie's uprising in 1745, in 1789 these two Orders formed a partial amalgamation as the Grand United Order of Oddfellows. These days they are more commonly known as "The Grand United Order of Oddfellows Friendly Society" (GUOOFS),^[24] abandoning all political and religious disputes and committing itself to promoting the harmony and welfare of its members. Some books mention that there was a lodge of a 'Union Order of Oddfellows' in London in 1750, and one in Derby in 1775.^[25]

The Oddfellows Magazine of 1888 included a picture of a medal presented to the secretary of a lodge of the Grand Independent Order of Oddfellows in 1796. In a magazine review of a 1798 sermon preached in the Sheffield Parish Church, the "Oddfellows appear to be very numerous with about thirty-nine lodges of them in London and its vicinity, two at Sheffield, and one at each of the following places: Wolverhampton, Birmingham, Shrewsbury, Windsor, Wandsworth, Canterbury, Liverpool, Richmond in Surrey and Lewes".^[26] This suggested that the "Original United Order of Oddfellows" consisted of a total of 50 lodges at that time.

In 1810, various lodges of the Union or United Order in the Manchester area declared themselves as an "Independent Order", and organized the "Manchester Unity of Oddfellows" which chartered the Odd Fellows in North America in 1819.^[27][28]

• 1748: Earliest surviving records of an oddfellows lodge is the manuscript of the rules, dated 1748, of the Loyal Aristarcus Lodge No. 9 which met in the Oakley Arms in Southwark, the Globe Tavern in Hatton Garden and the Boar's Head in Smithfield, London.^[2][29]
• mid-18th century: Order of Patriotic Oddfellows^[4]
• mid-18th century: Ancient Order of Oddfellows^[4]
• 1798: Grand United Order of Oddfellows ^{[c] [d]}
• 1810: The Independent Order – Manchester Unity^[e]
• 1810: Nottingham Ancient Imperial Order of Oddfellows^[30]
• 1820: Improved Independent Order of Oddfellows (South London)^[30]
• 1827: Caledonian Lodge of Oddfellows,^[31][32] based in Newburgh fife, is the only lodge of oddfellows left in Scotland
• 1832: Ancient and Noble (Bolton Unity) split from the Grand United Order in 1832, dissolved in 1962^{[citation needed]}
• 1832: Ancient National Order of Oddfellows (Bolton)^[30]
• 1832: Nottingham Odd Fellows, split from the Manchester Unity in 1832.^{[citation needed]}
• 1834: Leeds United Order of Oddfellows^[30]
• 1840: Independent Order of Oddfellows (Kingston)^[30]
• 1845: National Independent Order of Oddfellows^[30]
• 1849: Independent Order of Oddfellows (Norfolk & Norwich Unity)^[30]
• 1850: Independent Order of Oddfellows Manchester Unity Friendly Society^[e]
• 1853: Improved Independent Order of Oddfellows (London)^[30]
• 1858: Free and Independent Order of Oddfellows^[30]
• 1861: Ancient Independent Order of Oddfellows (Kent)^[30]
• 1867: British United Order of Oddfellows^[30]
• 1883: Scottish Order of Oddfellows^[31][33]
• 1900: National Independent Order of Oddfellows^[33][34]
• 1910: Caledonian Order of United Oddfellows^[31][33]

• Ancient and Noble Order of United Oddfellows^[31][33]
• Independent Order of Oddfellows Bolton Unity Friendly Society^[31][33]
• Independent Order of Oddfellows Kingston Unity Friendly Society^[31][33]
• Independent Order of Oddlittlefellows Madison Unity Friendly Society^[31][33]

• 1819: Independent Order of Odd Fellows (IOOF)^[35] formed in 1819 in Baltimore by Thomas Wildey, chartered by the British Manchester Unity, separated in 1842, today with lodges in approximately 29 countries.
• 1843: The American Grand United Order of Odd Fellows (GUOOF) formed in 1843,^[d] receiving its charter from the British Grand United Order of Oddfellows (rather than the American IOOF).^[15]

The Catholic Church in the 19th and early 20th centuries condemned secretive societies such as the Freemasons, deemed "pseudo-religious", but also addressed other organisations, including expressing suspicions against the stated religious neutrality and independence of Oddfellows.^{[36][failed verification]}

In 1907, the Apostolic Delegate to the United States, the Most Rev Diomede Falconio, in reply to a query from the Rev Novatus Benzing, OFM, of Phoenix, Arizona, determined that the Daughters of Rebekah, the auxiliary of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, as well as the female auxiliaries of other condemned secret societies, fell under the same category of condemnation.^{[citation needed]}

However, permission for "passive membership" in female groups affiliated with societies condemned by the church in 1894 (including the Knights of Pythias and Sons of Temperance) could be granted individually under certain conditions, viz. that the person in question had joined the group in good faith before the condemnation, that leaving the group would cause financial hardship due to the loss of sick benefits and insurance, that if permission is granted dues would only be paid by mail, the parishioner would not attend any lodge meetings, and the society would not have anything to do with the person's funeral.^[37]

Since 1975, however, several Catholic priests have become members of the Odd Fellows. One of them was Father Titian Anthos Miani who joined Scio Lodge No. 102 of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows in Linden, California.^[38] As soon as the controversy declined and religious leaders began to accept secular organizations, numerous pastors, priests, bishops and rabbis from different religious sects have become members and some even held leadership positions in the Odd Fellows.^[38] However, since the new code of Canon Law did not explicitly mention Masonic orders and other secret societies, the Office of the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued a declaration on Masonic associations in 1983, stating clearly that the opposition of the Catholic Church stated in the earlier version of the Canon Law had not changed.^[39]

• Fraternal order
• Freemasonry
• Secret society

The origins and history of the Oddfellows are not easily verified; some of the possible facts are mixed with unverifiable myth, legend, folklore and opinion. The following is a far-from-exhaustive list of "histories" of Oddfellows – unfortunately, few of them quote their sources.

• Burn, PPGM, of Glasgow (c. 1846), Historical Sketch of Oddfellowship, Manchester: A. Heywood{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
• James, Dr Bob (2010), They Call Each Brother – Secret Societies and the Strange Death of Mateship in Australia, 1788–2010. Self-published.
• James, Dr Bob, Odd Fellows, The Australian Centre for Secret Societies, Fraternalism and Mateship (i.e. Self-published.). Contains numerous articles and, according to its author, "is constantly being updated".
• Moffrey, Past Grand Master Robert (1904), The Rise and Progress of the Manchester Unity of the Independent Order of Oddfellows, 1810–1904, Manchester: The Grand Master & Board of Directors of the Order, Printers John Heywood.
• Spry, J (1867), History of Oddfellowship, Paternoster Row, London: Fred Pitman deals, as set forth on its title page, with "Its origin, tradition, and objects, with a general review of the results arising from its adoption by the branch known as the Manchester Unity from the year 1810 to the present time." The book was published by Fred Pitman, of London, and by the author at Plymouth.
• "History : The history of our society". GUOOFS (The Grand United Order of Oddfellows Friendly Society). Retrieved 1 January 2015.
• History of the IOOF in Marin County, archived from the original on 19 January 2013.
• "Odd Fellows Cemetery, Knoxville, KT". wbir.com. Archived from the original on 2 January 2015. Retrieved 3 January 2015.
• Odd Fellows Rest, the history of an IOOF cemetery in New Orleans.
• Brooks, Charles H. (1902), The Official History and Manual of the Grand United Order of Odd Fellows in America, Odd Fellows' Journal Print, p. 274