2016 South Korean legislative election

Legislative elections were held in South Korea on 13 April 2016. All 300 members of the National Assembly were elected, 253 from first-past-the-post constituencies and 47 from proportional party lists. The election was an upset victory for the liberal Democratic Party, which defied opinion polling by winning a plurality of seats in the election and defeating the ruling conservative Saenuri Party by one seat. In votes for party lists, however, Democratic Party came third, behind the Saenuri Party in first place and the new People Party in second.

2016 South Korean legislative election

← 201213 April 20162020 →

All 300 seats in the National Assembly
151 seats needed for a majority
Turnout58.15% (Increase 3.91 pp)
 First partySecond party
 
LeaderKim Chong-inKim Moo-sung
PartyDemocraticSaenuri
Last election127 seats[a]157 seats[b]
Seats won123122
Seat changeDecrease 4Decrease 35
Popular vote8,881,369 (C)
6,069,744 (P)
9,200,690 (C)
7,960,272 (P)
Percentage37.0% (C)
25.5% (P)
38.3% (C)
33.5% (P)
SwingDecrease 0.9% (C)
Decrease 11% (P)
Decrease 5.0% (C)
Decrease 9.3% (P)

 Third partyFourth party
 
LeaderAhn Cheol-soo
Chun Jung-bae
Sim Sang-jung
PartyPeopleJustice
Last election
Seats won386
Seat changeNewNew
Popular vote3,565,451 (C)
6,355,572 (P)
395,357 (C)
1,719,891 (P)
Percentage14.9% (C)
26.7% (P)
1.6% (C)
7.2% (P)
SwingNewNew


Speaker before election

Chung Ui-hwa
Saenuri

Elected Speaker

Chung Sye-kyun
Democratic

The election marked an upheaval in the South Korean party system, installing a hung parliament for the first time since 2000 and a three-party system for the first time since 1996.[1] The People Party attained a kingmaker position in the new Assembly, while the leadership of the Saenuri Party including chairman Kim Moo-sung resigned en masse following their defeat, relinquishing control of the party to an emergency response commission.

The 2016 legislative election was the first to be held in South Korea following the formation of the People Party and the enforcement of controversial Constitutional Court rulings dissolving the left-wing Unified Progressive Party and mandating the redistricting of the Assembly's constituencies.

Background

edit

In the 2012 legislative election, the ruling conservative Saenuri Party won a slim majority of 152 seats out of 300.[2] The party also retained control of the presidency, as Saenuri candidate Park Geun-hye won the presidential election that year. By the time of the 2016 legislative election, the Saenuri delegation had fallen to 146 out of 292 filled Assembly seats, exactly 50%.[3] The 2016 election was seen as an important stepping stone to the 2017 presidential election, which was held on 9 May 2017.[4]

Redistricting

edit

In 2014, the Constitutional Court of Korea mandated that because the population disparities between the Assembly constituencies were resulting in unequal representation, the constituencies must be redistricted for the 2016 elections. The Court held that the largest and smallest constituencies by population must not differ from each other by more than 2:1, and that the number of constituents in any given constituency must not differ from the average number of constituents by more than one third.[5]

A deadline of 31 December 2015 was set for the redistricting to take place. Nonetheless, by the end of 2015 the National Assembly had not approved a new electoral map. Viewing the situation as an emergency, the National Election Commission was forced to allow registered candidates to campaign without a set map of constituencies.[6] The crisis was ultimately resolved in February 2016 with an agreement between the two major parties that allowed a new electoral map to be passed by the National Assembly. The new set of provisions raised the number of districts from 246 to 253, while decreasing the number of list-selected seats from 54 to 47.[7]

RegionNumber of seats changedRegionNumber of seats changedRegionNumber of seats changed
Seoul48 → 49+1Ulsan6 → 60South Jeolla11 → 10−1
Busan18 → 180Gyeonggi52 → 60+8North Gyeongsang15 → 13−2
Daegu12 → 120Gangwon9 → 8−1South Gyeongsang16 → 160
Incheon12 → 13+1North Chungcheong8 → 80Jeju3 → 30
Gwangju8 → 80South Chungcheong10 → 11+1Sejong1 → 10
Daejeon6 → 7+1North Jeolla11 → 10−1Proportional representation54 → 47−7

Reordering of the opposition

edit

In the aftermath of the 2013 South Korean sabotage plot, another controversial Constitutional Court ruling enforced the dissolution of the Unified Progressive Party due to the party's alleged ideological affinity to North Korea. The dissolution of the UPP left the Justice Party as the sole left-wing democratic socialist party in the National Assembly. The Korean Confederation of Trade Unions, the most influential democratic trade union organisation in Korea that had originally supported the UPP, now endorsed the Justice Party. The Justice Party's candidates and Assembly members were considered to have similar political views as the left-wing members of the main opposition Democratic Party, and many votes from the Justice Party shifted to the Democratic Party.[8]

The opposition was further fragmented when Ahn Cheol-soo defected from the main opposition Democratic Party and established a new People Party in early 2016. Due to South Korea's largely first-past-the-post electoral system, the division between the liberal Democratic and People parties had led to projections of a sweeping victory for the ruling Saenuri Party in the elections.[2][9] The two opposition parties considered an electoral alliance but by 5 April the idea was abandoned, with interim Democratic leader Kim Chong-in stating that his party "will hold the elections whether the People’s Party is there or not".[10]

Legislative gridlock

edit

The outgoing 19th National Assembly was marked by political gridlock. In February 2016, Democratic lawmakers undertook the world's longest filibuster to stall an anti-terrorism bill, and the Assembly passed less than a third of the bills introduced in its term. The Saenuri Party aimed to win a supermajority of 180 seats in the 2016 election so that it could ease the gridlock by repealing the existing requirement for three-fifths of the Assembly to agree to the introduction of each bill.[11]

Electoral system

edit

300 members of the National Assembly were elected in the 2016 elections, of whom 253 (84%) were elected from single-member constituencies on a first-past-the-post basis, and 47 (16%) from closed party lists through proportional representation by the Hare quota largest remainder method, in accordance with South Korea's Public Official Election Act.[7][12] In order to win seats through proportional representation, parties needed to pass an election threshold of either 5 single-member districts or 3% of the total list vote.[13]

Restrictions on candidates

edit

Candidates for the National Assembly were required to pay a fee of 15,000,000 South Korean won (US$13,000 as of April 2016), and under the National Security Act the Constitutional Court may block the registration of "left-wing", "pro–North Korean" parties, though this provision had not affected the previous election in 2012.[14]

Date and process

edit

The 2016 election for the National Assembly was held on 13 April, in accordance with Article 34 of the Public Official Election Act, which specifies that Election Day for legislative elections is held on "the first Wednesday from the 50th day before the expiration of the [National Assembly members'] term of office".[15] Eligible voters were required to be registered and at least 19 years old on the day of the election,[14] and needed to show an approved form of identification at the polling place. Polls on Election Day were open from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Korea Standard Time (21:00–09:00 UTC, 12–13 April).[16]

Since 2009, voters have been able to vote overseas,[14] and the election began with registered overseas voters casting ballots between 30 March and 4 April.[17] For the first time in a national election, the National Election Commission also allowed early votes to be cast at polling stations in Korea without notice.[18] This early voting period lasted from 8 to 9 April,[19] in which time the NEC reported a high turnout of 12.2%.[20]

Political parties

edit
PartiesLeaderIdeologySeatsStatus
Last electionBefore election
Saenuri PartyKim Moo-sungConservatism
152 / 300
145 / 300
Government
5 / 300
[c]
Democratic Party of KoreaKim Chong-inLiberalism
127 / 300
[d]
103 / 300
Opposition
People PartyAhn Cheol-soo
Chun Jung-bae
ReformismDid not exist
20 / 300
Opposition
Justice PartySim Sang-jungProgressivismDid not exist
5 / 300
Opposition
Minjoo PartyGang Sin-seongLiberalismDid not exist
1 / 300
Opposition
Unified Progressive PartyLee Jung-heeProgressivism
13 / 300
DissolvedOpposition

Four major parties contested the 2016 election:[21]

Two other parties had one member in the outgoing National Assembly: the religious conservative Christian Liberal Party,[26] and another center-left party known as the Minjoo Party.[27][n 1]

Candidate nominations

edit

The Saenuri Party's candidate nomination process proved contentious. Several members of the Saenuri nominations committee accused party chairman Kim Moo-sung of becoming unduly involved in the process, and the party deselected a number of candidates who were seen as being opposed to the party leadership and President Park Geun-hye.[28] Many of the deselected candidates defected from the party and announced that they would run as independents. On 4 April, a spokesman for the party said that "during the candidate selection process, we upset our people and [the number of] our supporters who may not vote is worse [than we expected]."[29] The party published a theme song apologizing for the nominations controversy.[30] It also is thought by many that it was the main reason that caused the Saenuri Party to lose.

Campaign

edit

Campaigning for the election officially began on 30 March, lasting until 12 April. Under South Korean law, candidates were only permitted to campaign in a limited fashion before the beginning of the designated period, including sending a maximum of five text messages publicizing themselves to each voter.[31]

National security issues

edit

National security issues were a topic of contention in the campaign between the Saenuri and Democratic parties, though the People Party focused on other policy areas.[32]

The Saenuri Party argued for a hard-line approach to North Korea, and Saenuri chairman Kim Moo-sung accused the main opposition Democratic Party of pro–North Korean activity due to its support for the reopening of the Kaesong Industrial Complex,[30] an industrial park operated collaboratively by North and South Korea that had been closed down in February 2016.[33] The Democratic Party sought to portray the reopening of the complex as an economic rather than a political issue.[32]

The South Korean government announced a series of defections from the North in early April, with critics viewing the announcements as an electoral strategy on behalf of the ruling party.[34] A local media report quoted an unnamed government official as saying that the Blue House had overruled the Ministry of Unification's objections to publicizing the defections.[35] The Ministry of Unification denied any connection between the announcements and the election campaign.[36]

Candidates from both the opposition and the ruling party also pledged to push for the relocation of U.S. military bases from their constituencies.[37]

Economic issues

edit

The Korean economy was a dominant area of debate,[38] as the governing Saenuri Party promoted business-friendly economic reforms while opposition parties attacked the government for presiding over a historically high youth unemployment rate and declining economic growth.[39] The Saenuri Party sought to gain support for labor reforms initiated by President Park, which aimed to cut unemployment by increasing contract flexibility. Trade unions attacked the plans, arguing that the new laws would strip away necessary protections from workers.[40] The Democratic Party accused the ruling party of economic mismanagement,[41] and used the campaign to push for "economic democratization" and a shift from larger conglomerates to small business;[42] the party also promised to raise pensions and the minimum wage, to sponsor public housing development,[39] and to expand mandatory youth employment quotas.[43] Critics argued that Democratic plans would have a distortionary effect on the labor market.[43] Sim Sang-jung, chairwoman of the left-wing Justice Party, argued that the Saenuri, Democratic, and People parties had all failed to articulate distinctive economic policies.[44]

Social issues

edit

Speaking in Seoul during the campaign, Saenuri chairman Kim Moo-sung described homosexuality as "an outrage against humanity",[41] urging voters to reject candidates who supported LGBTQ rights.[45] He described Democratic assemblywoman Nam In-soon as a pro-gay advocate for supporting the revision of a military criminal law in 2013 to include men as well as women as potential victims of sexual assault.[41] The Christian Liberal Party also rallied vociferously against LGBTQ rights and stoked Islamophobia, calling on voters to "protect our families from homosexuality and Islam".[26]

Opinion polls

edit
Graph of selected opinion polls for the 2016 legislative election, beginning at the end of 2015 with the first polls accounting for the new People Party. The moving average is calculated from the last three polls.
  Saenuri
  Democratic
  People
  Justice
(      Poll embargo period)

Opinion polls from prior to the election had suggested the Saenuri Party would win the election outright, and were confounded by Saenuri underperformance in constituencies and the comparative success of the Democratic and People parties.[46][47] The KBS exit poll on 13 April showed the Saenuri Party winning a plurality with between 121 and 143 seats, and the Democratic Party taking 101–123; other exit polls projected similar results.[48] South Korean law had prohibited the publication of opinion polls in the week before the elections, beginning on 7 April.[49]

DatePolling firmSaenuriDemocratic[n 2]PeopleJusticeOth.Lead
13 Apr 2016Election (PR)33.525.526.77.26.98.0
5–7 Apr 2016Hankook Research28.421.716.94.45.16.7
4–6 Apr 2016Gallup Korea392114518
4–6 Apr 2016Realmeter34.427.316.88.34.47.1
28 Mar – 1 Apr 2016Realmeter37.126.214.88.53.810.9
29–31 Mar 2016Gallup Korea372112516
29–31 Mar 2016Hankook Research30.922.711.85.73.38.2
27–29 Mar 2016R&Search35.822.411.58.013.4
21–25 Mar 2016Realmeter38.324.914.08.54.013.4
22–24 Mar 2016Gallup Korea39218518
21–22 Mar 2016R&Search39.021.511.26.917.5
14–18 Mar 2016Realmeter41.528.312.36.93.813.2
15–17 Mar 2016Gallup Korea41208721
13–15 Mar 2016R&Search39.022.711.76.816.3
7–11 Mar 2016Realmeter44.127.811.15.72.216.3
8–10 Mar 2016Gallup Korea39238416
6–8 Mar 2016R&Search40.126.010.64.114.1
29 Feb, 2–4 Mar 2016Realmeter43.728.011.54.53.615.7
2–3 Mar 2016Gallup Korea38239415
28–29 Feb 2016R&Search37.524.58.95.313.0
22–26 Feb 2016Realmeter43.526.712.14.73.116.8
23–25 Feb 2016Gallup Korea42198323
21–22 Feb 2016Hankook Research38.315.97.12.43.222.4
15–19 Feb 2016Realmeter41.726.711.73.53.315.0
16–18 Feb 2016Gallup Korea422010222
10–12 Feb 2016Realmeter39.725.912.95.73.413.8
1–5 Feb 2016Realmeter40.227.015.04.43.513.2
2–4 Feb 2016Gallup Korea392012319
25–29 Jan 2016Realmeter40.626.913.13.43.813.7
26–28 Jan 2016Gallup Korea392012319
18–22 Jan 2016Realmeter39.225.017.14.63.914.2
19–21 Jan 2016Gallup Korea381913319
11–15 Jan 2016Realmeter36.122.520.73.74.813.6
4–8 Jan 2016Realmeter36.120.318.73.85.815.8
28–31 Dec 2015Realmeter35.223.617.3[n 3]5.85.011.6
21–24 Dec 2015Realmeter37.222.419.0[n 3]6.13.014.8
11 Apr 2012Last election (PR)42.836.5[n 4]10.3[n 5]12.96.3
General notes
  • Gallup Korea provides poll results only to the nearest whole number.

Results

edit
Sealed ballot box used for this election

Prior to the election, it was widely expected that the Saenuri Party would emerge victorious due to divisions in the opposition and an intensified national security climate.[50] Speculation had focused on whether the party would be able to attain a three-fifths majority.[51] In contrast to expectations, however, the Saenuri Party was delivered a decisive defeat, losing not only its majority but also its status as largest party in the Assembly.[52] The Democratic Party took a one-seat plurality, and the opposition outnumbered the governing party for the first time in 16 years,[1] while the centrist People Party also emerged as a new force in South Korean politics, holding the balance of power in the elected Assembly.[1] The result was seen as posing significant problems for then-President Park,[52] who was rendered unable to press forward with her legislative agenda without opposition support.[53] News sources labelled Park a "lame duck" president,[54] with the Chosun Ilbo saying that her "lame duck period has started earlier than any other administration in the past".[55]

Eleven independents were elected, of whom seven were former Saenuri members who had been deselected by the party in the nominations process prior to the election: Yoo Seong-min, Joo Ho-young, Ahn Sang-soo, Yoon Sang-hyun, Kang Ghil-boo, Chang Je-won, and Lee Chul-gyu.[56] Meanwhile, a number of high-profile Saenuri figures were defeated in the constituency elections, including Oh Se-hoon, former Mayor of Seoul, who had been positioning himself for the 2017 presidential race; senior lawmaker and former presidential candidate Lee Jae-oh; and Deputy Prime Minister and former party chairman Hwang Woo-yea.[57]

PartyProportionalConstituencyTotal
seats
+/–
Votes%SeatsVotes%Seats
Saenuri Party7,960,27233.50179,200,69038.33105122–35
People Party6,355,57226.75133,565,45114.852538New
Democratic Party6,069,74425.55138,881,36937.00110123–4
Justice Party1,719,8917.244395,3571.6526New
Christian Liberal Party626,8532.6401,3760.0100New
Minjoo Party209,8720.88017,0340.0700New
Green Party Korea182,3010.77031,4910.13000
People's United Party145,6240.610154,4020.6400New
Christian Democratic Party129,9780.5500New
Hannara Party86,4640.3602,2320.01000
Labor Party91,7050.39046,9490.2000New
Green Buddhist Federation31,1410.1300New
Let's Go! Korea27,1030.1102530.0000New
Let's Go! Peace and Human Rights Party25,2270.1100New
Welfare National Party20,2670.0901,2950.0100New
United Korean Party16,4270.0700New
Korean National Party16,4070.0701,0740.0000New
Republican Party12,2950.0503,2680.0100New
Employment Welfare Pension Advancement Coalition12,1430.0502,1490.0100New
Chinbak Yeondae11,9810.0500New
Pro-Ban Unification Party9,7100.0409,3940.0400New
Truth Party3,2510.0100New
Patriotic Party8460.0000New
Pro-Peace Peace Unification Party5190.0000New
National Anti-Corruption Party4920.0000New
Republic of Korea Party2640.0000New
Independents1,683,2647.011111+8
Total23,760,977100.004724,002,420100.002533000
Valid votes23,760,97797.2624,002,42098.53
Invalid/blank votes669,7692.74358,3361.47
Total votes24,430,746100.0024,360,756100.00
Registered voters/turnout42,100,39858.0341,893,93658.15
Source: NEC

By region

edit

The table below lists constituency totals and list vote percentages in each region. Since the election was run under a parallel voting system, electors could choose to vote for one party in their constituencies while voting for another party's national list. Exit polls indicated that 12.9% of those who had voted for the Saenuri Party in their constituencies and 20.8% of those for the Democratic Party supported the People Party list.[58]

Constituency and party list results by region[59]
RegionSaenuriDPKPPJPOtherInd.Total seats
Seats%Seats%Seats%Seats%SeatsSeats
Seoul1230.83525.9228.808.506.0049
Busan1241.2526.6020.306.005.9118
Incheon433.4725.4026.907.506.8213
Daegu853.1116.3017.406.107.1312
Gwangju02.9028.6853.307.307.908
Daejeon331.0428.2027.107.606.107
Ulsan336.7022.8021.108.7010.736
Sejong028.6028.5026.608.907.411
Gyeonggi1932.34026.8027.017.806.1060
Gangwon643.4123.9019.305.707.718
North Chungcheong538.6327.6021.405.606.808
South Chungcheong637.0527.1022.505.607.8011
North Jeolla17.6232.3742.808.109.2010
South Jeolla15.7130.0847.805.8010.7010
North Gyeongsang1358.1012.9014.805.209.0013
South Gyeongsang1244.0324.4017.416.507.7016
Jeju035.0329.6022.407.006.003
Constituency total105110252011253
PR list1733.51325.51326.747.207.047
Overall total122123386011300

Aftermath

edit

The day after the election, Saenuri chairman Kim Moo-sung tendered his resignation over his party's defeat, saying that he would "take responsibility for the resounding defeat in the general elections"; Kim Tae-ho, a member of the party's Supreme Council, and secretary-general Hwang Jin-ha also announced their resignation.[60] After the mass resignation of the party leadership, the party established an emergency committee led by floor leader Won Yoo-chul to lead the party on an interim basis.[61] In order to regain the party's plurality in the Assembly, Won announced that Saenuri would receive independent lawmakers who had previously been deselected by the party back into its ranks. Ahn Sang-soo, one of the deselected candidates who had re-entered the Assembly as an independent, declared his desire to rejoin the party, while another, Yoo Seong-min, stated that he would rejoin at an appropriate time.[56]

President Park stated on 18 April that she "humbly accepted" the election result, and would "closely cooperate with the new National Assembly".[62][63] A survey conducted in the two days following the election showed Park's approval rating falling to 31.5 percent, her lowest ratings in office yet and 8.1 percentage points down from the week before the election.[62]

The election was seen to have a limited effect on the Korean stock market, since the prospect of a hung parliament appeared to diminish the chance of ambitious economic policies being implemented.[64] Nonetheless, on a more limited scale, the performance of companies tied to prominent figures reflected the election results: shares in AhnLab, Inc., whose founder and largest stakeholder is People Party co-chairman Ahn Cheol-soo, had risen 5.2% by 2 p.m. KST on 14 April following Ahn's election success, while textile company Chonbang, chaired by Kim Moo-sung's brother, fell 19.2% in the same time frame.[64]

See also

edit

Notes

edit
  1. ^ Unless otherwise specified, "Minjoo" or "Minjoo Party" refers to the main opposition Democratic Party of Korea, not the minor party.
  2. ^ Known as the New Politics Alliance for Democracy until 28 December 2015.
  3. ^ a b Speculative support for "Ahn Cheol-soo's new party".
  4. ^ Democratic United Party result.
  5. ^ Unified Progressive Party result.

References

edit